The Campaign for Free Expression

Search
Close this search box.

Released on: December 7, 2021

SANEF and CFE fight SABC’s bid to hold Magopeni’s disciplinary action behind closed doors

The South African National Editors’ Forum (Sanef) and the Campaign for Free Expression (CFE)
are taking action to ensure that the SABC’s disciplinary action against Phathiswa Magopeni,
the public broadcaster’s head of news, takes place openly and transparently.
Sbu Ngalwa, the chairperson of Sanef, said: “An open and transparent process will not only
assist the public to make up its mind on the case, but it will also aid the SABC to dispel the
perception that the process is part of a political witch-hunt.
“Sanef reiterates its respect for the SABC’s internal processes and being able to hold staff
accountable – hence we are not calling for the disciplinary action to be abandoned but rather
for it to be open to the public as the issues at hand are a matter of great public interest,” said
Ngalwa.
The CFE’s executive director Anton Harber, CFE said: “Too much is at stake for this to happen
behind closed doors. Ms Magopeni has said that she is being hounded out because she has
resisted political interference. We need the public to see if this is a return to the days when
factional politics dominated the SABC and buried its public service mandate”.
Lawyers for Sanef and CFE have written to the chair of the hearing, Advocate Nazeer Cassim,
to ask that the media be allowed to attend the proceedings. Cassim has asked the Sanef and
CFE legal team to argue the case for openness when the hearing begins on December 17. The
SABC has already refused a Sanef request to open the hearings, so they are expected to
oppose it.
“The SABC is no ordinary employer,” Sanef and CFE argued. “The public broadcaster plays a
unique role in South Africa’s deliberative democracy, which it can either foster or undermine
… Ms Magopeni’s grievance … squarely impugns the SABC’s impartiality and independence.
“Whether she indeed acted negligently in breaching a court order is a matter of public
interest,” the two organisations said.
Magopeni has been charged with negligence and bringing the SABC into disrepute after the
broadcaster ran an episode of its investigative programme Special Assignment in
contravention of a court order.
In a formal grievance, Magopeni argued that she is being held to account for a decision that
was not hers, as it was made four levels below her.
She alleges she is being targeted because she resisted attempts by the SABC chair and Group
CEO to force her to carry an unscheduled interview with President Cyril Ramaphosa during
the recent local government election campaign.
The action against Magopeni came just days after Fikile Mbalula, the ANC’s head of elections,
blamed the SABC for his party’s election performance and pointed a finger at Magopeni
personally.
The SABC has been on the right course to restore its public service values and to reverse the
damage caused by years of political interference and manipulation. As a society we must be
vigilant to prevent this from happening again.
*CFE is a non-profit body dedicated to defending and expanding the right to free expression
for all in southern Africa.
*SANEF is a non-profit organisation whose members are editors, senior journalists and
journalism trainers from all areas of the South African media. SANEF is committed to
championing South Africa’s hard-won freedom of expression and promoting quality, ethics
and diversity in the South African media.
Contacts:
For CFE: Anton Harber, 0833039497, anton@harber.co.za
For Sanef: Sbu Ngalwa, 0734041415

Media statement

Related Media Releases

Botswana media and civil society highlight threats to free expression in the run up to elections

July 22, 2024
Civil society representatives, journalists, academics and free expression activists have expressed serious concerns and highlighted a number of recent transgressions that threaten the integrity of Botswana’s Oc……

Read More

Magopeni case victory

January 13, 2022
The public won the right to watch the SABC’s disciplinary action against news editor-in-chief Phatiswa Magopeni, thanks to the Campaign for Free Expression (CFE) and the SA National Editors’ Forum (SANEF). “It ……

Read More